Attention Hockey Cameramen/Women
Is it just me? Why on earth, when I watch an HD broadcast of a hockey game, does the camera insist on fluttering around, following the puck? Guys...the viewfinder for an HD camera is rectangular! The playing surface of hockey is...rectangular. Why the need to shift the camera back and forth to follow the flow of the puck? I'm missing all the off the puck action!!
Example...a typical HD broadcast gives me 1/3 of the screen with the crowd, yet, I cannot see all the way down to the near boards.
Also...when the puck is in the attacking zone, I get to see the puck moving about, but I miss what the defensemen are doing at the blue line (are they open? are they asleep?).
The great thing about most HD sets is they are huge and flat. Unlike old standard definition TV's which tend to have a rounded screen and the edges of the picture would get a bit blurry...HD is crisp throughout. My eye can follow the play if it goes from the bottom left hand corner to the upper right hand corner...there is no need to move the camera. Why not just pan the camera at an even level...back and forth as the play flows from one end to the other?
Here is a great example of how to use the full screen of an HD camera...
Now, I do understand that there is still the need to broadcast the game in standard definition, as well as HD. So, the whole point of having the bigger screen is lost, because of their efforts to keep it within the confines of the SD square. Well, screw that...just show the game.
I guess its like having play by play guys on the TV telling you what is happening, when I can clearly see what is happening, why do you need to tell me. Perhaps that is why I enjoy Jim Houghson so much...he just tells me who the players are, fills me in on where they are from and gives decent anecdotes about the game. Too many guys out there (mostly with USA based teams) yell at me in an effort to 'create' excitement. Look if the game is boring...its boring. But, I digress.
Perhaps in a few years, when HD is the only broadcast system, camera men and women will be able to relax and bit and only follow the flow of the game from side to side in the field of play, instead of showing only the puck. Hockey is a game of finding the open man...and the open man is rarely where the puck is. Allow me the freedom to find the open man on my big, 47inch screen...and stop yelling at me.


